We're going to rate eye-catching cards that we come across. And whatever else. For instance, when a baseball card blog post catches our eye, for better or worse, we may rate that. These ratings are set in stone. They can never be altered because the committee is reclusive and cranky.
The possibilities are zero up to four dings in five categories, one of which will always be random. The highest score is 20. We would greatly appreciate if you email us scans of cards, or whatever, as long as it's somewhat relevant, to rate. If you dare.
Here's a sample.